In the average home, up to 40% of the total energy used is for temperature control. One way to decrease this cost is by adding blow-in insulation to the exterior walls and attic space. Doing this can save 20-30% on your heating bills.
There are two main types of blow-in insulation: cellulose and fiberglass. Cellulose insulation is made from ground up used newspapers and cardboard, with chemicals added for fire retarding and to deter rodents, insects, and mold. Fiberglass is molten glass that has been spun or blown into fibers. Each has its advantages and disadvantages, some of which will be explored here.
R-Value
R-value is the measurement of the insulating property of a material. It measures how well the material resists the flow of heat. The higher the R-value, the more insulation from heat a material provides. Blow-in insulation comes with recommendations for depth and density of application. These should be strictly adhered to in order to insure the proper insulation value.
Blown-in cellulose insulation provides an R-value of 3.6 to 3.8 per inch. In order to achieve R-38 (the standard for attic insulation), there would need to be 10-12 inches of insulation in the space.
Blown-in fiberglass provides an R-value of 2.2 to 2.7 per inch. Therefore, 14-17 inches of insulation material would be needed to reach R-38.
Looking at the straight numbers, cellulose seems to be the winner in insulation value. However, there is another factor that should be taken into consideration: settling. Cellulose settles more over time than fiberglass, and can lose up to 20% of its insulation value. Therefore, it is recommended that 20% more material than is needed be installed, in order to compensate for this loss.
Material Content
Cellulose is made up of up to 85% recycled newsprint. Borate and ammonium sulfate are added as a fire retardant, and to deter rodents, insects and mold. These chemicals have been determined to be safe for humans, although masks should be worn during installation.
Fiberglass contains 20-30% recycled glass, which is spun or blown into fibers. Often formaldehyde is added, although insulation companies are now coming out with formaldehyde-free insulation. Formaldehyde is a known carcinogen, and can off-gas through the walls into the living area. Fiberglass itself was declared a possible carcinogen by the federal government in 1994. This is due mostly to the amount of fibers that become airborne during installation. Installers are required to wear masks.
Both materials pose hazards to the installers, and are relatively safe once installed and sealed in the building cavities. Cellulose uses more recycled materials, but may not be as fire resistant as fiberglass. Both types of insulation must be carefully installed around light fixtures and other electrical heat sources.
Installation
Both types of blow-in insulation are installed in basically the same way. The most popular method for exterior walls is called the “two-hole” method. It involves cutting two 2” diameter holes, one 16” below the top of the wall, and the other 24” from the bottom of the wall. This is done in each stud cavity of the wall. Insulation is blown-in from both holes until the desired concentration is reached. Then each hole is sealed and patched.
Attics are insulated either through the attic access in the home, or by drilling holes in the ceiling or between roof rafters. These holes are also sealed and patched once the required depth and density is reached.
Conclusion
The addition of blow-in insulation is a great way to retrofit an existing house and improve energy efficiency. Of the two most popular materials, cellulose and fiberglass, there is no one clear winner. Each has its pluses and minuses. There are many qualities to consider, such as the materials and chemicals used in each one, and the insulation value. It is up to the homeowner and installing contractor to decide which is best for each situation.
Sources
Note by Blair Edmiston:
To a large degree, I agree with Dawn. I think that Cellulose is a clear winner since it is recycled and actually more fire resistant with the additives. Also, if compacted cellulose gets wet it doesn't lose its insulative value.